A teacher in our school today returned from a course today and announced that "we shouldn't be giving the children homework anymore is it turns them off learning." According to the AQA, who where running the course, homework turns children off learning by making them too tired.
Obviously overjoyed by the thought of not having to set homework and mark it I looked into this a little more when I got home tonight and came across the following article. According to the Independent:
"A new study to be published in the UK this spring claims that too much study
after school turns children off education and sparks family rows. The book, The
Homework Myth, by American academic Alfie Kohn, also claims that it does not
help them to do well in tests, either.
There is international evidence to suggest Alfie Kohn may have a point on the
test scores, if children are set too much homework. The Third International
Maths and Science Survey, published in 1998, found that children who did a
moderate amount of homework did a little better than those who do a lot or very
little. For instance, the Finns, who do less homework than the British, score
considerably better in international tests - coming top of almost every table
for maths and science achievement through the ages of compulsory schooling. The
Italians, who do more homework than the British, do less well.
However, Kohn, a lecturer and writer about education, psychology and
parenting from Belmont, Massachusetts, would argue there should be no homework
set at all. "Kids should have the chance to relax after a full day at school,"
he says. Primary school children should do no more than read for pleasure once
they get home, he adds."
To article continues looking at the pros and cons and makes interesting reading.
My big problem with traditional homework is how helpful it actually is? A lot of the time the work comes back in (apart from the hardcore of children who just never complete the homework) it is in someone else's handwriting, or 100% correct when I just know that the child would not have been able to get them all right. When asked who helped they reply that they did it by themselves. Should I be marking parents, brothers or aunties work?
At my school we've started moving away from traditional homework. My last piece of homework over the holiday was to make something to do with the current topic we are covering. The children were specifically told not to write anything.
The quality of the work that was returned after 3 weeks was stunning. Children worked with their parents to create fantastic models, 3D pictures, mobiles and experiments all related to space. The parents commented how much they enjoyed completing the homework with the children. We've now put it all together to make a giant museum, with labels and instructions on how it was made, which the children happily show off to anyone that will look.
Surely this is way forward for homework... Why not try it the next time you set a homework task?
Recent Comments